EXPOSING HIDDEN TRUTHS
A letter from Michael Lanzdorf to the Racine County board of supervisors dated November 13th, 2026
Below for the challenged like me in enlarged print
Michael J. Lanzdorf
Corporation Counsel
730 Wisconsin Avenue
Racine, WI 53403
262 - 636 - 3874
fax: 262 - 636 - 3549
Michael.Lanzdorf@RacineCounty.gov
To: Racine County Board of Supervisors
From: Michael J. Lanzdorf, Corporation Counsel
Cc: Christopher Schmaling, Sheriff
Donald Vandervest, Sheriff-Elect
Ralph Malicki, County Executive
Date: November 13, 2026
Re: Independent Preston Kite Investigation and Review
This memo addresses the independent investigation and review (commonly referred to informally as the “Hall Report(s)”) performed by the law firm of Crivello, Nichols & Hall, S.C. stemming from the arrest of former deputy Preston Kite. It is intended to provide greater transparency while respecting and preserving fundamental legal obligations (including attorney-client privilege), employee privacy, and the integrity of the investigative process.
Investigations of misconduct within the Racine County Sheriff’s Office (“RCSO”) are typically
entrusted to its professional standards unit – and also, in certain circumstances (e.g., allegations
of sexual harassment or retaliation), human resources and/or in-house legal – without
involvement of the Board of Supervisors (the exception being instances where the subject of
recommended discipline requests a hearing before the Grievance Committee). Allegations
involving and/or potentially implicating senior leadership, significant financial risk, and
anticipated litigation, however, may warrant engagement of outside legal counsel. In those
instances, such independent investigation and review (i.e., beyond the typical representation in
civil claims and/or legal action) may be justified because internal teams (e.g., RCSO leadership,
command staff, investigators, HR professionals, etc.) may face real or perceived conflicts of
interest and to preserve investigation integrity. Whereas internal teams may unintentionally allow
bias, personal relationships or fear of internal politics to influence an investigation, outside
counsel provides greater certainty of objectivity and credibility through independence. It bears
further mention, however, that the reason for external investigation goes beyond mere
independence. In such instances (as was the case here), outside counsel may be commissioned to
provide legal advice and to evaluate legal risk, analyze applicable laws, advise decisionmakers,
recommend corrective action, and prepare the organization for potential litigation.
With that in mind, in early 2024, the Racine County Sheriff commissioned Crivello, Nichols & amp;
Hall to conduct an independent investigation and review stemming from the actions and arrest of
former deputy Preston Kite. The investigation was separate and distinct from the Kite criminal
investigation, which – due to Kite’s employment with Racine County – was conducted by the
Kenosha County Sheriff’s Office and led to a host of serious criminal charges and, ultimately,
Kite’s conviction and incarceration.
The commissioning of Crivello, Nichols & Hall occurred on the advice (and pursuant to the
authority) of counsel and at the behest of the Racine County Sheriff, a constitutional officer, with
the concurrence of then-County Executive Jonathan Delagrave and County Board Chairman Tom
Kramer, with the directive to comprehensively and independently review allegations of
misconduct or policy violations for the earlier-stated reasons and to help ensure the RCSO
continues to uphold the culture and standards expected of Racine County and of such a highly
regarded law enforcement agency. The investigation was conducted to draw upon the law firm’s
specialized expertise and, in an objective and independent manner, to provide advice and
recommendations designed to strengthen integrity, accountability, legal compliance,
organizational effectiveness, and to ensure readiness for potential litigation (and attendant legal
and financial risk that could ultimately be borne by taxpayers).
Following the news of Kite’s arrest, the RCSO received tips and reports of strange and
inappropriate conduct that Kite had engaged in both socially as well as professionally with the
RCSO. The law firm’s investigation occurred over the course of roughly 12 months and included
interviews of not less than 13 witnesses of varying rank and responsibility within the RCSO (and
courts) and review of voluminous records. It is important to note that all interviews were
voluntary and no individual was compelled to appear or offer any information. The interviews
focused on three primary areas of information: (i) the nature and extent, if any, of direct contact,
personal experiences, and/or firsthand knowledge related to Kite; (ii) “rumors” or secondhand
information they heard related to Kite; and (iii) the overall culture within the RCSO related to
misconduct and reporting of the same.
Three internal review reports – two dated December 2, 2024, and the third (representing a brief
follow-up regarding a discrepancy in the timeline of events) dated February 4, 2025 – resulted
from the investigation. The key conclusions and recommendations of the Crivello, Nichols &
Hall investigation and review follow: (i) although the investigation concluded that there was not
evidence of widespread misconduct or sexual harassment within the RCSO, there was a
recommendation for a personnel review and potential re-training of staff and supervisors on
identifying and reporting sexual harassment, along with an anonymous employee reporting
mechanism; and (ii) there was a recommendation that a personnel investigation be conducted
related to Captain Cary Madrigal’s response to allegations that another deputy received
inappropriate photos from Kite. 1 Those findings and recommendations specifically related to
Captain Madrigal later served as the basis for initiation – and implementation – of a disciplinary
complaint from within the RCSO. In response to public records requests for, among other things,
Captain Madrigal’s disciplinary file, the Office of Corporation Counsel (“Office”) concluded that
there were no statutory or other exceptions to disclosure of the disciplinary complaint (which,
1 Facts and information related to Captain Madrigal’s discipline are discussed here on the basis that it was the
subject of circuit court action, Cary Madrigal vs. Racine County, 2026CV000280 (Filed Feb. 2, 2026). The subject
records (containing the facts and information referenced herein from the internal review report and follow-up
internal review report) were ordered to be released to the public pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 19.356(5). See Order, dated
May 22, 2026.
notably, included detailed, verbatim accounts of the investigation’s findings and
recommendations that were specific to Captain Madrigal). This Office also applied the public
records balancing test and did not identify any public interests that would outweigh the strong
presumption and public interest in favor of disclosure of the records. Racine County sent notice
of its decision to release the requested records as required by law and, subsequently, defended
against and prevailed in a legal challenge that sought an order to restrain the County from
providing access to the disciplinary records.
Reports of the investigation’s believed findings (beyond the publicly disclosed disciplinary
records) have circulated and become amplified (and took on gross mischaracterization) during
the course of the recent sheriff’s election, begging the simple question: Why aren’t the Crivello,
Nichols & Hall investigation reports being released publicly? In short, maintaining the
confidentiality of the investigation protects the privacy of RCSO members (and others) –
particularly subordinate staff – who volunteered to participate and were forthcoming with
information, promotes the willingness of witnesses to participate in any future investigations by
allaying concerns relating to privacy or risk of retaliation, preserves investigative integrity, and
limits exposure for and likelihood of claims of retaliation. See also Wis. Stat. § 19.35(1)(am)(1)
(right to inspect or copy does not apply to any record collected or maintained in connection with
a complaint, investigation or other circumstances that may lead to an enforcement action,
administrative proceeding, arbitration proceeding, or court proceeding). Additionally, release
may jeopardize both the personal privacy and safety of witnesses and could inhibit future candid
assessments and participation in critical investigations of this sort. In other words, the suggestion
that release of the Crivello, Nichols & Hall investigation is warranted in the interest of
transparency actually touches on a classic legal and policy paradox: in limited instances (such as
this), protecting confidentiality is actually necessary to keep the public informed and systems
accountable (e.g., it led to the disciplinary complaint that was publicly disclosed on
determination of this Office and by order of the Racine County Circuit Court) because forced or
reckless disclosure often can have the chilling and irretrievable effect of destroying the flow of
information altogether.
The confidentiality of the Crivello, Nichols & Hall investigation is also covered and justified
under the legal doctrine of attorney-client privilege (including mental impressions, legal theories,
and legal strategy). The attorney-client privilege – codified under Wis. Stat. § 905.03 and
supported by Wisconsin Rules for Professional Conduct for Attorneys, SCR Ch. 20 – rests upon
two fundamental assumptions: effective legal assistance requires full disclosure of a client’s legal
problems, and that a client will only reveal the details required for effective representation if
confidences are protected. Those justifications have not been offered flippantly, to conceal
misdeeds, or shield high-ranking officials. This Office recognizes that the Wisconsin public
records law, Wis. Stat. §§ 19.31-19.39, reflects a strong policy of transparency and accountability
and that Wisconsin laws favor the broadest practical access to government, as evidenced by its
determination that the Madrigal disciplinary records should be released and subsequent circuit
court decision denying efforts to enjoin Racine County from releasing such records. However,
attorney-client privilege protections serve the important purpose of enabling candid legal advice, corrective action, and effective litigation preparation. In sum, waiver of attorney-client privilege is an extraordinary step that should not be taken lightly as release of the Crivello, Nichols & Hall investigation would have a lasting and chilling effect.



No comments:
Post a Comment